Water rights hearing to resume with Part 2 on February 8
From the Cal Water Fix Hearing Team at the State Water Resources Control Board:
This ruling addresses the outstanding motions for continuance of Part 2 of the hearing in this matter. On January 12, 2018, Save the California Delta Alliance (SCDA) moved for a continuance of the hearing while the hearing officers address alleged ex parte communications between State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board or Board) staff and staff and consultants of the Department of Water Resources (hereafter, DWR staff).1 Deirdre Des Jardins with California Water Research joined the motion in part and added a motion for a “partial conversion” of the proceeding.
Ms. Des Jardins also submitted a separate motion for continuance on January 28, 2018, on grounds similar to those included in SCDA’s motion. On January 15, 2018, County of Sacramento, Sacramento County Water Agency, County of San Joaquin, City of Stockton, Sacramento Regional County Sanitation District, City of Antioch (Antioch), and Local Agencies of the North Delta filed a request for stay or continuance of the hearing pending the production of public records, formal discovery, and a hearing to address the alleged ex parte contacts between State Water Board staff and DWR staff. The request was joined by numerous parties.3 On January 19, 2018, DWR submitted a consolidated opposition to SCDA, et al.’s, and County of Sacramento, et al.’s respective motions for continuance. On February 5, 2018, we received a motion from Patrick Porgans seeking a continuance and entry of alleged ex parte communications into the record on grounds substantially similar to those raised in SCDA, et al.’s motion.
On January 25, 2018, Antioch submitted a separate motion for continuance in which it urged:
(1) re-opening Part 1 based on changes to the proposed operational scenario for the WaterFix Project and (2) continuing Part 2 based on reports that DWR and the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation (collectively, Petitioners) are considering modifying the proposed project to comprise one tunnel rather than two. DWR opposed Antioch et al.’s motion on January 30, 2018. On January 31, 2018, the Natural Resources Defense Council, Defenders of Wildlife, and The Bay Institute (collectively, NRDC, et al.) filed a motion to continue Part 2 based on similar reports that Petitioners were considering a one-tunnel proposal.On January 17 and 31, 2018, we directed hearing team staff to cancel hearing days prior to February 8, 2018, to give us time to review the procedural motions addressed by this ruling. We have now independently reviewed the motions, joinders, oppositions, and supporting materials.
For the reasons discussed below, we find that no changes to the WaterFix project have been proposed that would warrant re-opening Part 1 or staying Part 2 at this time. Further, we find that the communications between State Water Board staff and DWR staff that are the subject of the motions either concerned non-controversial, procedural issues or were properly limited in scope to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) consultation between lead agency and responsible agency to ensure analysis of an adequate range of alternatives. We find that those communications did not violate the law prohibiting ex parte contacts, nor are the communications evidence of an unacceptable risk of bias that would warrant disqualification of hearing team members or the decision-makers in this proceeding. Finally, the possibility that grounds for a stay or other procedural steps could be found in responses to pending Public Records Act (PRA) requests does not justify granting a stay now.
Therefore, all motions addressed by this ruling are denied.
Read the full ruling letter here: 20180206_cwf_ruling
——————————————–
Sign up for daily email service and you’ll always be one of the first to know!
- Sign up for daily emails and get all the Notebook’s aggregated and original water news content delivered to your email box by 9AM. Breaking news alerts like this one, too. Sign me up!
Maven’s Notebook
constantly watching over the world of California water
